She’s looking out for herself and her daughters above all else, and making sure that nothing gets in the way of that. My guess is the view is from the south and the actual location was East Boston. As I stated in another post, from a writer's perspective, the call is simply the mechanism that allows the characters to break the case. What the hell is with Sean Penn’s wife’s speech at the end? Dave was obviously broken emotionally. They were all affected by Dave’s abduction. The lives of three men who were childhood friends are shattered when one of them has a family tragedy. I thought the movie was ending right when Sean Penn confessed to Kevin Bacon what he had done. Mystic River is his most complex and assured effort to date, a near-classic that falters due to an accretion of many small flaws and one large one. at the parade, the fake gunshot again bears an intended meaning and jimmy smiles back in a mocking fashion. It only takes a minute to sign up. Kevin Bacon’s wife was waiting for an apology. The film seems to suggest that all the trouble was caused by Dave’s abduction, but clearly the boys are already headed in their separate ways before that happens (Jimmy suggests taking a car, Sean says his dad would kill him if they did, Dave is the wimpy one). But then a strange car pulled tip to their street. The acting though, was brilliant. One more feasible explanation can be that after listening to the tape Sean and Whitey had gone to question Brendan about those two boys whom Katie might have known or have grudge against. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Were we supposed to feel that his death was justified or in some way better than him staying alive?**. I didn’t recognize it. Abducted. This book is the average mystery book on steroids. It seemed to me this indicated that the kid was aware that his mother mistakenly fingered his father. ** It doesn’t come across clearly enough in the movie that she is a Savage. What did this have to do with the movie? Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. I thought it was a good movie, but had a few too many “Hollywood” conventions for my taste (swooping crane shots, swelling music, other minor details here and there) which didn’t make me like it less, but tempered my enthusiasm. I agree that the movie could have just ended with Jimmy’s comment that he hadn’t seen Dave since he drove off in the back of the car. One of the niggly things that bothered me about the movie was this: the dead daughter was both shot and beaten. Remember Annabeth’s blustering father in the beginning of the movie,at the wake? ** and it was the friend on the line. Why the hell does Sean(Bacon) do NOTHING? About your first theory: did Sean and Whitey know that it was Silent Ray and John O'shea who called 911? The Ending of ‘Bliss’ Explained February 6, 2021; ... and one of his last was 2003’s Mystic River. Mystic River Our movie maestro Thomas Wartenberg says that Clint Eastwood’s recent film Mystic River is a tragedy – but in the good sense of the word. I didn’t really get the ending though. think that the ending of Mystic River was poor. The sub-plot with Sean’s (Kevin Beacon) silent wife should also have been excised. Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. "Mystic River" takes a final explosive turn into a complex double denouement that involves both the gun as a murder weapon and an explanation of the suspicious activities of Dave Boyle the night of Katie's murder. ** By cleaning up your local watershed, you not only benefit your community—you also help prevent this litter from going downstream and ultimately ending up in the ocean. I’m right with you, randwill, I didn’t get it. The worst thing about the movie was those horrible reddish “anti-piracy” dots that took me right out of the movie. But they had his prints on the murder weapon. I didn’t really get the ending though. Just saw the file and my take on the ending of the movie is: 1. How should I refer to my male character who is 18? Mystic River er en amerikansk film fra 2003 i regi av Clint Eastwood, publisert av Warner Bros. og manus ble skrevet av norsk-amerikaneren Brian Helgeland basert på en roman av Dennis Lehane. What was he talking about when he kept saying “I know you … Isn’t that what foreshadowing is for? Against whom was the Tree of Life guarded after the fall of Adam and Eve? i do think that it was symbolic of his destiny as dave’s son being fulfilled - he was also now lost and alone and without strength, much like the way his father’s life had played out. Benchmark test that was used to characterize an 8-bit CPU? I’m pretty sure that “Buckingham Flats” and “Rome Basin” are made up, but I kept trying to orient the action based on the frequent views of the Tobin Bridge (from the end of the street where the kidnapping happens). Why did Jessica not believe the tape which mentioned her rape? ** There were several things about the film that bothered me, and I’d love to hear anyone’s perspective on any of them. I thought that this was odd. Mystic River. i actually think bacon did a pretty decent job in this movie (for him), but it was a difficult thing for him to reflect what that character was supposedly going through in limited screen and devoted story time. But at the time they entered John had already drawn a gun over Brendan. 4) Was Dave abusing his/some kid, or was he so confused that he didn’t know what he was saying? Synopsis : Jimmy Markum, Dave Boyle et Sean Devine ont grandi ensemble dans … I don’t get the whole parade sequence. Eagle River is a new animated desktop wallpaper from the EleFun Multimedia Company. So they probably just wanted to talk to Brandon about the 911 tape. Remember Annabeth’s brothers, the Savages? In “Mystic River” how come no one mentioned the second murder? It’s a shame that far too often, I don’t get around to reading a book until after the movie is out (“Seabiscuit” is another recent one) but I suppose, better late than never. Dave's car had been impounded because of … For those looking for the Royal Mail, you can find it at Louis Merse's home (he is also the one you go to when you fulfill a monster contract). Sean did feel remorse for killing the wrong guy, and his wife’s Lady Macbeth routine was indeed to lift his spirits but also to encourage him to take strength from his act, and rule all he surveys (his extended family, his neighborhood etc.). In the ending sequence, all of the principals were attending the town's parade. Mystic River and Unforgiven are my two favorite Clint Eastwood films and depending on which one I see last I tend to put in first place. It’s only when he finally says “I’m sorry” at the end that she finally starts talking. What stops a teacher from giving unlimited points to their House? his wife was telling him that he owns this town and that he needs to do what he needs to do, plain and simple. In Mystic River, Sean and Whitey don't have a clue about the real killers of Katie until they finally listen to the 911 tape. Floor-to-ceiling bookshelf before or after carpet? She doesn’t come right out and say it was a good thing he killed Dave, but certainly that he is willing to take even drastic actions to protect his family is presented to Penn as a very positive attribute that he shouldn’t feel sorry for. Likely some other Doper will be more articulate than I, but this, FWIW, is my take on the movie. Was he just referring to his previous self as “kid”? What happens to the mass of a burned object? **, The way I read this situation was as one of disassociation, alienation. I, too, was bothered by the speech at the end by Annabeth, however the part that bothered me most is that she seemed totally remorseless about Dave’s death because she thinks that Celeste deserves to be alone, because “…who says things like that about her husband?” Creepy. 3) What was the point of the sub-plot about Sean’s missing wife? Through the morally complex characters, the novel considers the lasting imprint of trauma and childhood friendships and evaluates the true meaning of loyalty and justice. Crazy British Femizon TV show/movie - 1970s. The studios are ruining film prints on purpose! What can I do to (non abusively) get him to always be tucked in? At the very end of the movie, Sean (Bacon) pointed a gun with his fingers at Jimmy (Penn) from across the street during the parade. The movie seemed to imply that Sean wasn’t even going to investigate Dave’s disappearance. – Shiz Z. Dec 3 '12 at 22:36. add a comment | 2 Answers Active Oldest Votes. he curses him and tells him he’ll prove dave’s murder, jimmy basically challenges him to give it a shot. Were we supposed to feel that his death was justified or in some way better than him staying alive? Caprese nailed it with Annabeth. And yes, I took it that it was better to die than remain his live, tortured self. Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor, Visual design changes to the review queues. finds out that Deaf Brother took the gun. Of course, the very next day, the cops announce that they caught someone else who confessed to killing the young woman -- and by the way, in an unrelated case, a child molester had been killed that same night, and the cops suspect Dave did it. I agree 100% with richardb on Annabeth’s speech. The Mystic River lies to the north of Boston and flows approximately parallel to the lower … I think this is borne out by the comment (I forget by whom) that Brendan signs to his brother even though he doesn’t have to, just to make him feel less like an outsider. Mystic River ending? Kevin Bacon’s wife was waiting for an apology. Added nothing. If you hadn’t read the book, you’re confused about who The Kid is, you have no idea why Celeste is so afraid of her husband that she rats him out to Jimmy, and you don’t know how truly amoral Jimmy is. He certainly wouldn’t have been the one to make the 911 call (how could he have heard the question about the name?) Good movie. [QUOTE] I agree with your sister, I don’t think the gun gesture was anything threatening. rev 2021.2.16.38590, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Movies & TV Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. The past haunts us. sean’s wife - somebody mentioned this also, that she was waiting for an apology. The film should have ended when Jimmy (Sean Penn) says: “The last time I saw Dave was when he went up this road in the back of that car.”. This is not a nicey-nice family that Jimmy has married into. I agree that this could be the movie that finally wins an Oscar for Penn but Robbins was quite good too. **, I understand your confusion; having read the book, her speech did not come so out of left field for me. Sean and Whitey knew enough facts about the case to at least make a weak connection to Silent Ray and John O'Shea after listening to the tape. the whole movie involved him on a low level debating whether he had been in the wrong in driving her away or if she was in the wrong…and on a high level, debating whether his occupation had driven him to become that very type of man who would be in that situation. Mystic River continuously outflows its poignant crime investigation through a meticulously gritty screenplay. A naive boy that just didn’t know any better. The ending to Mystic River (plot spoilers)... O.K. But I’ve seen people who read the book say it was more than that. I felt that the story had tied itself up nicely after the scene in the street with Sean Penn, Kevin Bacon, and the names in the concrete. River flows in the forest very quickly. The only thing I didn't understand was right at the end, Jimmy asks his wife why she didn't call him and she goes into her talk about how he knows what has to be done, and that he could rule the town. However the elder Harris had passed his polygraph with flying colors as mentioned by Sean. This tells Sean that the caller probably knew more about the case - but how did they make the connection to Silent Ray and his friend Johnny? Durata 137 min. Katie was killed in the Harris' neighborhood, assumedly on her way to Brendan's house (they were leaving for Vegas the next day.). Anyway, I just finished the movie and thought I would google what people thought about the ending. The film, adapted from Dennis Lehane’s bestselling novel, is … The story seems unbelievable, and the grief-stricken father kills Dave. You can tell from the call that they were kids and they knew that the victim was a girl but were obviously trying to hide what they knew. Photo Competition 2021-03-01: Straight out of camera. A majority of litter found in the ocean comes from rivers. in that sense, such a gut-wrenching case put him through a variety of emotions. Hence they might have taken a wild guess that mute Harris junior might have access to that gun and he was always with his friend John. I always end up liking the book better anyway. I think Tim Robbins’ aged, ragged look was sort of part of his shambling, Sad Sack act. And that’s just my take…. His home is locate… Un thriller ad alta densità psicologica. Simple. I had heard people talk about the ending. Caprese nailed it with Annabeth. I didn’t really get the ending though. i think that a read of the book is required to fully understand, or at least be able to consider, the final 10 minutes or so of the movie. As far as the deaf brother talking, I’m going to assume he can talk if he really wants to and the brother knows this, but for whatever reason the part with him actually saying something ended up on the cutting room floor. I’m right with you. Sometimes events like that can tear friendships apart rather than bring them together. The second one sounds quite reasonable though - the cops were not prepared for someone pointing a gun at them. Drammatico, USA, 2003. finds out that Deaf Brother took the gun. Any way the later still look more probable. I got in an argument over my sister about the gunshot gesture Sean makes at Jimmy. What was he talking about when he kept saying “I know you can talk?” Apparently he can’t, because we never see him talk. That at least warrants a conversation with the boys. Are SSL certs auto-revoked if their Not-Valid-After date is reached without renewing? On the former, yes, on the latter, that remains open for debate. It doesn’t come across clearly enough in the movie that she is a Savage. Origin of portable armor for a race of creatures. In one of the scenes one of the Savage Brothers said Katie was their niece, Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled. How come the cops didn't find the gun thrown in the shallow river? They assumed that Katie knew her killer because the old lady witness told them that she heard a "Hi" followed by the shot. So all of this adds up to (in Sean and Whitey's mind): How can all the evidence point to Brendan and yet, based on the polygraph, he is not the killer? Or was Brendan’s brother trying to kill her so that Brendan wouldn’t leave him to go to Las Vegas? The name Savage about covers it. Although tragedy is one of the classical genres of drama, it does not translate easily onto the silver screen. Was Dave abusing his/some kid, or was he so confused that he didn’t know what he was saying? annabeth’s speech at the end - the epilogue of the book is heavily focused in jimmy accepting that he is an evil man and that the most appropriate thing is for him to return to his life of not necessarily crime, but street justice. My sister thought it meant Sean was not going to investigate Dave’s diappearance, that the fake gunshot hand sign was his punishment and that Celeste would be mollified by the $800 payments presumably forthcoming. It involves three boyhood friends in an Irish neighborhood of Boston, who were forever marked when one of them was captured by a child molester; as adults, their lives have settled into uneasy routines that are interrupted by the … Sean notices that the caller refers to the victim as a she, although he couldn't know that the victim is a girl since he saw only the car and the body was dumped in the park. They knew that the gun used to kill Katie was the gun (not just caliber or type, but THE gun) that Just Ray used in a liquor store robbery years ago based on the ballistic analysis. Why does Sean not seem to feel remorse over killing Tim Robbins, and what’s with his wife’s weird megolamaniacal bent? Question about Mystic River ending...(spoilers inside) spoiler. Was this scene discussed in more detail in the book? Directed by Clint Eastwood. there is also a suggestion in the book that celeste had had a thing for jimmy - certainly acknowledged by him, probably suspected by annabeth as well. What is the name of this Nintendo Switch accessory? Mystery is one of my favorite genres, if it’s yours as well then this is the book for you. Inside it is a skeleton which will net you the captain's key. The film seems to suggest that all the trouble was caused by Dave’s abduction, but clearly the boys are already headed in their separate ways before that happens (Jimmy suggests taking a car, Sean says his dad would kill him if they did, Dave is the wimpy one). I seem to recall a few instances where Brendan spoke to him when they weren’t facing each other, most notably when he called to him in the market when he was leaving. She points out to him that he has two other daughters who need and rely on him and that the way she calmed them down was by letting them know their father would DO ANYTHING to protect them (even, I’m sure she doesn’t bother to mention to them, if he is mistaken in his “anything”) and therefore in a way what he did was a good thing. One boy got into the car, two did not, and something terrible happened — something that ended … In that chest is a journal; bring it to Flotsamand place it into the Royal Mail box. The resemblance to the English word mystic is a coincidence, which the colonists naturally followed.. In Mystic River, How did listening to the 911 tape solve the case? ** Yet, when her body was found, there was no sign of beating. Where was that park where the body was found? Isn’t that what foreshadowing is for? When Sean said that it was all an accident, I gave a bit “Huh?”. Was he just referring to his previous self as “kid”? Jimmy (Penn) was already on the edge (he had an abusive father in the book) but spun out completely against authority after the abduction. How did the tapes falling scene in the train trigger Ed Warren to check the tape? But then when it went on a little longer I expected some sort of twist ending. we lose dave, but this is as close to right that our own worlds have been in some time. totally bizarre behavior, i agree…but i think it feeds very well into this alternative “boston” universe that they try to create with jimmy and his followers. Is there the number `a, b, c, d, m` so that the equation has four integer solutions? (Not only that, there was also the matter of Jimmy’s earlier murder of “Just” Ray.). When they went to question Katie's boyfriend Brendan for the first time at his house they had met the Harris junior with his friend John O'shea too. Jadis, these aren’t reel-change marks, see this thread. My take on the wife’s speech was that she is specifically boostering Penn’s ego so as not to let him get debilitated by his remorse over killing his friend. I thought that the younger brother couldn’t speak, but could hear perfectly fine. The only connection they could make from the case was that the shot fired to kill Katie was fired using the gun of 'Just Ray'. I saw this, it was okay, but i thought i was ~20 mins too long. What was the point of the sub-plot about Sean’s missing wife? How do I read bars with only one or two notes? Mystic River's ending has always struck me as one of the most disappointing "deus ex machina" endings I've ever seen, so maybe this answer will help. Once police got them they confessed everything. The overall story was pretty good, Robbins was terrific. I thought that this was odd. As for the comment above about the red piracy dots…are you referring to the burn marks in the upper right hand corner that flash every 20 minutes or so? Lack of evidence. What are the main improvements with road bikes in the last 23 years that the rider would notice? So I don’t think he will start now. I definitely came to the conclusion during Brendan’s fight with Silent Ray that Ray had killed her in order to keep his brother from leaving him. Was it as Kevin Bacon paints it (initially the gun went off by accident, and then once they’d shot her once they decided to kill her so she wouldn’t talk). Did anybody else think this? This break through might look a little vague but still there was a shot in the dark for Sean and Whitey. since there is no good way to get inside of a person’s thoughts during a movie (somebody mentioned this earlier), i think eastwood felt that this was perhaps the best way to reflect that turn. ARGH! That key opens a chest farther in the wreck. *Originally posted by NoCoolUserName * Why does my PC crash only when my cat is nearby? Although it looks to be exaggerated but for investigative purpose they went to meet him. Chapter I: This quest begins in a shipwreck in the Kayran's lair. Why does Sean not seem to feel remorse over killing Tim Robbins, and what’s with his wife’s weird megolamaniacal bent? The murder of Sean Penn's daughter had nothing to do with the tragedy of all those year's ago. What happened to Tim Robbins on the night the crime had nothing to do with the murder of Sean Penn's daughter but was simply the wildest of disconnected coincidences. When Sean glanced at Jimmy, he mimicked shooting him. Huh? If you read Dennis Lehane’s most excellent book, you’ll get more insight into the characters’ childhoods and motivations, but really, Eastwood (and adapter Brian Helgelund) did a fine job bringing the novel to the screen. I don't think so, since they didn't mention a name. Mystic River features a moving screenplay, solid direction and a superb cast highlighted by Sean Penn's Oscar-worthy performance. I just finished Mystic River and I was very impressed. And she looked pretty fine in the morgue and in the funeral home. If so, those are standard in all films, they’re there to let the projectionist know when a reel change is coming up. I seem to remember Penn’s face looking a bit less troubled and distant after she says this and he hugs her. The Mystic River is a 7.0-mile-long (11.3 km) river in Massachusetts, in the United States.In Algonquan, missi-tuk means "large estuary," alluding to the tidal nature of the Mystic. It was pretty clear. Even the connection between Sean This sounds plausible, but I agree with NDp that it’s pretty ambiguous. We see that Katie’s Boyfriend (Brendan?) so what was the story here? It was more like just a way to illustrate Brendan’s enraged and irrational state of mind. Ah! Mystic River is a poignant exploration of human nature in the trappings of police procedural. Mystic River's ending has always struck me as one of the most disappointing "deus ex machina" endings I've ever seen, so maybe this answer will help. celeste and michael - i don’t necessarily agree to the extent that he knew she had done something to wrong the father. The very end...Jimmy (Penn) basically admits to killing Dave (Robbins) right to Sean (Bacon). With Sean Penn, Tim Robbins, Kevin Bacon, Emmy Rossum. How to write a portion of text on the right only? jimmy seems to smile back in appreciation, as if they can both be thankful for their return to normalcy. 5. Right now I’m inclined to declare Mystic River as Eastwood’s best film, but that is subject to change anytime (perhaps even before I … Forward or backward subject verb agreement. I was a little surprised that they put such an innocuous spin on the murder as well. Bottom line, it didn’t really matter if he could talk or not (at least in the final version of the movie), so I’m not going to worry over why Brendan yelled that at him. Annabeth’s speech comes out of nowhere. I just saw this movie and I have a few comments: I see a few people refer to “the deaf kid”, but my impression from the movie was that he was not deaf, but mute. Dave (Tim Robbins) reveals that he didn't kill Jimmy's (Sean Penn) daughter - he actually killed a child molester. Where in the world can I travel with a COVID vaccine passport? I had no idea that Anabeth was related to the Savage Brothers. What was the actual murder motive? Sean (the Kevin Bacon character, not Sean Penn) was motivated to become a cop largely by his feelings of helplessness and guilt over his inability to stop Dave’s abduction. Good question. There was lots of good stuff in the film, also–camera work, acting and so forth, but the questions are making me nutz.